A new Health Justice Monitor commentary on the intrigues of the medical lobbies.
“The pharmaceutical industry needs to come under control of our own public single payer, and the health insurance industry needs to be converted into public stewards serving all of us as we dismiss the private entrepreneurs who are draining the system.”
By Don McCanne, MD
Summary
The pharmaceutical industry conducted a poll to elicit views from Americans about how insurance impairs access and affordability, for healthcare overall and drugs in particular. The concerns are real. The battle among health system profiteers is intriguing … will internecine struggles help us achieve real health care reform?
Excerpt
New Ipsos Poll Shows Americans Are Frustrated with Abusive Insurance Practices That Exacerbate Access and Affordability Challenges
PhRMA
March 1, 2022
According to a new Ipsos/PhRMA poll, nearly 9 out of 10 Americans (86%) agree that Congress should focus on cracking down on abusive health insurance practices that make it harder for people to get the care they need. The sentiment is shared widely among both Democrats (92%) and Republicans (84%). Voters overwhelmingly support policies that would lower out-of-pocket costs and bring greater transparency and accountability to the health insurance system.
According to the Ipsos/PhRMA poll, Americans would like to see Congress focus more on reducing the overall costs of health care coverage such as premiums, deductibles, and copays (71%) over reducing the costs of prescription drugs (29%).
In the past year, 43% of people who take prescription medications have themselves or their families faced at least one insurance barrier to their care. These experiences range from waiting for an insurer to approve a medicine their doctor prescribed (prior authorization) to the insurer requiring a patient to try a different medicine (fail first), or not covering a doctor-prescribed medicine at all (formulary restriction).
82% agree that lowering out-of-pocket costs for health care should be a top priority for Washington.
Commentary
Comment by: Don McCanne
High out-of-pocket health insurance costs have been of great concern to Americans, but so have high costs for prescription drugs. Solutions for both problems would be found through an efficient, equitable means of health care financing – a universal single payer system, but both the insurance industry and the pharmaceutical industry remain opposed because single payer systems place the patient first rather than directing excess funds to their own industries.
This particular release is interesting because PhRMA, representing the pharmaceutical firms, has decided to attack the insurance industry as they escape out the back door with the loot (though the insurance industry led with prior authorization, fail first, and formulary restrictions). Undoubtedly Congress is the target of this message, but we can only hope that they will hold in their hearts where the relief needs to be directed, and that, of course, is the patient. The pharmaceutical industry needs to come under control of our own public single payer, and the health insurance industry needs to be converted into public stewards serving all of us as we dismiss the private entrepreneurs who are draining the system.
It’s nice that PhRMA wants something done about insurance costs, but it is unfortunate that they dismiss the importance of reducing the cost of prescription drugs. In doing so, they have inadvertently reinforced the importance of adopting a universal, equitable, public health care financing program. But we know that Congress understands this; let’s be sure that they act upon it.
Subscribe to Health Justice Monitor
The McCanne Health Justice Monitor (HJM) is a health policy blog focused on the U.S. health system failings and single payer reform. A core team of health policy experts and guest contributors write posts several times per month, addressing topics ranging from healthcare inequity and waste, distortions introduced by profit motives, racism and racial inequities in health care, climate and environmental justice, global health and more.
HEAL California is an independent news and information hub focused on the Medicare for All movement.
With non-partisan news, views, podcasts and videos, we highlight the on-going injustices of our broken healthcare system and amplify the voices of those who are most impacted by it.
Our Podcasts shine a light on the failures of America’s healthcare system, while explaining how Medicare for All could help.
Our Media page offers connections to experts and additional resources including links to legislation and studies.
Keep up with the Medicare for All movement!
Follow us on Facebook and Twitter, and subscribe for email updates.
